Features News Events Interviews Take me out Competitions RSS
On the cover
¹7 (2014)
Tunnelling Towards Hope

28 February - 6 March 2014

Ukraine History

A Stronghold of Rulers and Rebels

With the recent death toll jumping to nearly 100 and 1,000 injured, Hrushevskoho Street, one of the strongholds of EuroMaidan’s three-month-long protests, made headlines around the globe. It was here, on 19 January the country’s stand against government corruption, abuse of power, and the violation of human rights turned from peaceful protest to all-out revolution. Having witnessed much over the years, Hrushevskoho is a street with a history, and not only care of recent days.


Ukraine Today
Acelebrity using their status and intelligence to influence public views and opinion is rarely seen in modern society, even less so in Ukraine. Here, the majority of celebs use their time, effort, and money to enhance or further their career rather than put their name to something that can do good for others. However, as EuroMaidan intensifies, some are making themselves heard – and they fall either side of the EuroMaidan divide.
It used to be that when rebellion and revolution occurred, the intellectual, creative, and spiritual elite would be front and centre.


Ukrainian Culture

When Walls Can Talk

People have been writing on walls since the dawn of civilisation, we call it graffiti, and ranges from simple written words to elaborate wall paintings. Sometimes it is merely the creator wanting to leave his or her mark; sometimes there is an underlying social or political reason. And it is due to the latter that graffiti has exploded across Kyiv in recent months. Anti dictator messages aside, we peel back a few layers of paint to look at graffiti in the city in general.


Ukraine History

Arrogant, Ruthless…and Ukrainian? Leon Trotsky and Ukraine

For a long time, Trotsky for most young Ukrainians was no more than a mythic, and often demonised, character in the story of the October Revolution. Then Trotsky appeared as a character in the hit movie Frida (which partly concerns his dalliance with the artist Frida Kahlo), and he seemed a funny old fellow, full of his own, perhaps crazy, ideas. More recently What’s On’s Kateryna Kyselyova discovered that Trotsky had been born in Ukraine, and grew curious about the man.
Appropriately, Lev Trotsky was born Leyba Bronshteyn on the day Communists now celebrate the October Revolution: 7 November, 1879. He was the fifth child in the family of Jewish landowner Davyd Bronshteyn in the province of Kherson (today it’s Kirovograd oblast). His parents hailed from Poltava, indicating that they’d been in Ukraine for several generations.

Of course, Ukraine had been a zone of permanent Jewish settlement for a long time prior. Statistics show that by the end of the 19th century, nearly two million Jews lived within the borders of Ukraine. Though there were loud complaints about the harsh anti-Semitism in Ukraine, Jews were successful in nearly all branches of the economy, from banking to trade. They led textile, sugar and even railroad enterprises. By 1900, Volyn, Berdychiv and Odessa were hubs not only of Jewish culture, but of the Ukrainian economy. In particular, Odessa was the heart of Ukraine’s banking system, and its influence extended even to Moscow.
Such extensive Jewish success in the business and economic sphere frightened the reactionary tsarist regime in Petersburg. The public attitude toward Jews, never very welcoming, had been especially antagonistic since 1881, when Tsar Alexander II was assassinated. The government took official measures, introducing quotas on the number of Jews permitted into institutions of higher education. Only three percent of all students in Petersburg universities could be Jewish, and only 10 percent in the so-called Pale of Settlement. The Bronshteyn family was somewhat inured from this discrimination: first, they were wealthy, and second, they were quite assimilated. Historians state that Trotsky’s father spoke surzhyk (a mixture of Russian and Ukrainian), and that young Lev grew up speaking mostly Russian and Ukrainian, not Yiddish.
I was particularly curious to read about Trotsky’s childhood in Ukraine, so I picked up his two-volume memoir, ‘My Life,’ written by the cast-out Bolshevik in the 1930s. There he writes that his ethnicity did not play a major role in his childhood and youth; the tsar’s new restrictions prevented his father from buying any more land, but by unclear means he could rent it. “But that did not bother me much,” wrote Lev, “coming from a wealthy family I belonged to privileged circles rather than poor ones.” As a child, little Leyba wrote poetry. When his parents found out, they forced him to recite his work to guests. “I refused,” wrote Trotsky, “and at first they tried to convince me kindly, then strictly, then with threats…I often ran away, but finally would end up reading with tears in my eyes.” The modest, intellectual and romantic child would grow into a fanatical and cruel left-wing revolutionary.

University and Radicalism
Because of the quota, Trotsky was forced to delay his entry into college for one year. When he did enter Odessa college, he distinguished himself as one of the best students in all subjects. While studying, young Lev had many disagreements with his father, who wanted his son to become an engineer. In his own words, Trotsky hesitated between higher mathematics and revolutionary activity. He read progressive magazines, disputed Darwinian theory and talked about revolution while drinking tea with his friends. In fact many Jewish youth were attracted to the idea of revolution, a stance motivated in part by the tsarist government’s restrictions on the Jewish populace. Lenin himself was later to hold the Jewish effort in the revolution in high esteem, noting that the percentage of Jews in proletarian organisations was always higher than that of other nationalities. Jews were not only better represented in these groups, but generally attained a higher rank as well. On the other hand, many Jews supported Ukraine’s Tsentralna Rada in its fight for autonomy and independence. Jewish people suspected that a more independent Ukraine would be a much better place for them to live than under the Tsar or a Soviet Ukraine.
In the late 1890s, Trotsky became involved with revolutionary circles, and in Mykolaiv in 1898 he was arrested for distributing propaganda. While imprisoned, he became an adherent of Marxist ideology, read some of Lenin’s works, studied languages and married his revolutionary companion Alexandra Sokolova. While they were exiled in Siberia, the Bronshteyn family had two daughters. In the beginning of the 1900s, Lev escaped, leaving his wife and children behind. On his way abroad he forged a passport in a new name. Henceforth he would be known Lev Trotsky.

Trotsky and the Bolsheviks
He made his way to London in 1902, and went straight to Lenin’s apartment. His arrival early in the morning woke Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin’s wife, who opened the door. Thus began his association with Lenin, a relationship full of arguments and ideological conflict. Even though he had difficulties with Lenin, after the Revolution Trotsky later occupied many important posts in the Soviet government, among them Minister of Foreign Affairs and head of the Red Army. In the military, his techniques were particularly harsh, and he executed or imprisoned many soldiers to enforce discipline.
Trotsky was an early supporter of a Soviet Ukraine, too. At first, Lenin thought that an independent but friendly Ukraine would be better than a restless and uneasy Soviet republic. Trotsky, knowing the region better, disagreed. He wrote in 1918: “Ukraine has millions of people capable of work. It has metal, coal, bread. If we lose Ukraine, we’ll lose the basis for Soviet power.”
After Lenin’s death, a power struggle ensued among the ruling Bolsheviks. Stalin and Trotsky hated each other, and by the end of the 1920s, Trotsky had been dismissed from his post and exiled with his family from the Soviet UNI0N. He lived in Turkey, France, Norway and eventually Mexico, where he had his encounter with Kahlo. It was a period of furious activity for Trotsky, who penned some of his fundamental works, such as the ‘History of the Russian Revolution’ and the theoretical basis for the Fourth International. But Stalin never lost sight of his old nemesis. Soviet agents worked to find him. Their first attempt to assassinate him failed, but the second, in 1940, was successful: an NKVD agent hit Trotsky in the head using an axe, killing the famous revolutionary.
In his memoirs, Trotsky quotes the French anarchist and revolutionary Proudhoun: “The movement is no doubt irregular and crooked, but the tendency is constant. What every government does in turn in favour of revolution becomes inviolable; what is attempted against it passes over like a cloud: I enjoy watching this spectacle, in which I understand every single picture; I observe these changes in the life of the world as if I had received their explanation from above; what oppresses others, elevates me more and more, inspires and fortifies me.” To which the former Bolshevik adds: “Those are fine words. I subscribe to them.” Trotsky was romantic and arrogant, a prisoner, perhaps, of his ideas - and utterly ruthless in their pursuit.

Kateryna Kyselyova

Go back

Comments (0)
You are not authorized! Only registered and authorized users can add their comments!

Print Print   Send Send    In favorites In favorites

Read also:
  • A Stronghold of Rulers and Rebels
  • More Than A Square
  • Game of Thrones
  • A Divisive National Hero
  • The Ukrainian Roots of Sholem Aleichem

    Global news 
  • Events Calendar
    «« October 2018 »»
    Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7
    8 9 10 11 12 13 14
    15 16 17 18 19 20 21
    22 23 24 25 26 27 28
    29 30 31

    Remember me
    Forgot your password?

    Ukraine Truth
    Rights We Didn’t Know We Had

    Throughout EuroMaidan much has been made of Ukrainians making a stand for their rights. What exactly those rights are were never clearly defined. Ukraine ratified the Univer­sal Declaration of Human Rights in 1952. The first article of the Declaration states all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights, they are endowed with reason and conscience, and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood. The ousted and overthrown Ukrainian government showed to the world they don’t understand the meaning of these words.

    Kyiv Culture

    Pulling Strings
    Located on Hrushevskoho Street – the epicentre of EuroMaidan violence, home to battles, blazes and barricades – children’s favourite the Academic Puppet Theatre had to shut down in February. Nevertheless, it is getting ready to reopen this March with a renewed repertoire to bring some laughter back to a scene of tragedy. Operating (not manipulating) puppets is a subtle art that can make kids laugh and adults cry. What’s On meets Mykola Petrenko, art director of the Theatre, to learn more about those who pull the strings behind the show.


    Essential Kyiv listings
    Car Rental
    Bars & Pubs
    Catering Services
    Courier Services
    Foreign Banks
    Hotel Service
    Internet Cafes
    Lost & Found
    Medical Care
    Language Courses
    Souvenir Shops
    Travel Agencies
    Real Estate
    Cable & Satellite TV
    Fitness Centers
    Flowers and Gifts delivery
    Food Delivery
    Freight Forwarders
    Internet providers
    Translation Services
    Veterinarian Clinics
    Beauty Salons
    Whatson Birdies Party

    Useful Links