Features News Events Interviews Take me out Competitions RSS
On the cover
¹7 (2014)
Tunnelling Towards Hope


more...
28 February - 6 March 2014

Ukraine History

A Stronghold of Rulers and Rebels

With the recent death toll jumping to nearly 100 and 1,000 injured, Hrushevskoho Street, one of the strongholds of EuroMaidan’s three-month-long protests, made headlines around the globe. It was here, on 19 January the country’s stand against government corruption, abuse of power, and the violation of human rights turned from peaceful protest to all-out revolution. Having witnessed much over the years, Hrushevskoho is a street with a history, and not only care of recent days.

more...


Ukraine Today
Acelebrity using their status and intelligence to influence public views and opinion is rarely seen in modern society, even less so in Ukraine. Here, the majority of celebs use their time, effort, and money to enhance or further their career rather than put their name to something that can do good for others. However, as EuroMaidan intensifies, some are making themselves heard – and they fall either side of the EuroMaidan divide.
It used to be that when rebellion and revolution occurred, the intellectual, creative, and spiritual elite would be front and centre.

more...


Ukrainian Culture

When Walls Can Talk

People have been writing on walls since the dawn of civilisation, we call it graffiti, and ranges from simple written words to elaborate wall paintings. Sometimes it is merely the creator wanting to leave his or her mark; sometimes there is an underlying social or political reason. And it is due to the latter that graffiti has exploded across Kyiv in recent months. Anti dictator messages aside, we peel back a few layers of paint to look at graffiti in the city in general.

more...


Ukraine History

The Famine, 75 Years Later

It’s one of the worst anniversaries in Ukrainian history: 27 November, the day Ukrainians commemorate the beginning of Stalin’s artificial terror-famine of 1932-33 – the so-called Holodomor that killed up to 10 million people. The famine represents one of the worst crimes against humanity in a twentieth century full of them, and a low point both for the resilient Ukrainian nation and the Soviet UNI0N. In memory of this unhappy anniversary, What’s On cast a glance back at an event the world still needs to know more about.


The famine, of course, was the Stalin regime’s attempt to deal with chronic ‘problems’ that bedeviled the relatively new Soviet state. The first of these was the peasantry’s unwillingness to voluntarily give up their land and join collective farms, like the Communists wanted them to. The second was the threat that the Ukrainian national movement, with its pretensions to independence, posed to a USSR that couldn’t afford to lose the agriculturally rich Ukraine – the lynchpin of successive Russian empires. But if Stalin’s treatment of Ukraine was a response to obstacles that stood in the way of the Kremlin’s control of the empire, the atrocity has roots that go back into revolutionary theory. Lenin and his fellow Bolsheviks simply didn’t know what to do about the Russian empire’s massive number of peasants, a majority of the population. Peasants didn’t fit right into Marxist theory, which saw the urban proletariat as the engine of history, and considered the religious, conservative peasantry, stubbornly attached to their land, to be an obstacle to socialist ‘progress’, if not outright enemies. A decade’s worth of Kremlin attempts to exert control over the countryside it nominally ruled ended in stalemate, with the peasants refusing to collectivise and give up their individualistic ways. And so, after Stalin consolidated his power in the late 1920s, Moscow began to turn up the pressure on the counterrevolutionary rural population. In 1929, the Moscow regime declared war against the Ukrainian peasantry under the slogan ‘dekulakisation’, with armed Communist activists violently seizing peasants’ land.

 A‘kulak’ (a slang word that literally means ‘fist’ in Russian) was supposedly an ‘affluent’ peasant who exploited his fellow community members, who in the twisted world of Soviet propaganda wanted Stalin’s goons to come and ‘liberate’ them from the wicked ‘class enemy’. Of course, ‘kulaks’ weren’t exploiters, but simply hardworking family farmers; anybody the Kremlin’s rural representatives didn’t like became a ‘kulak’. The policy was an excuse to whip up hysteria against a social group that wasn’t buying what the Stalinist regime was offering – the ‘urbanisation’ of the countryside based on the creation of gigantic communal industrial farms. Millions of kulak ‘class enemies’ were expelled from their land to try to find work in the cities, exiled to Siberia or simply shot in the back of the head and thrown into mass graves. Historical accounts testify to the lynch-mob cruelty with which so-called kulaks, whose ‘riches’ usually consisted of no more than a cow or two, were treated by the NKVD’s thugs. And yet, even the psychotic war against the kulaks didn’t break the anti- Communist will of the peasantry. They responded to Communist demands for grain and livestock quotas, and for their property in general, by killing their animals en masse before the Communists could requisition them and by hiding grain. The result of this war between the regime and its peasants was that the Ukrainian countryside (and, indeed, the countrysides of other Soviet Republics) became a disaster site. The result of the 1929-30 attempt at forced collectivization was a draw, in which both sides stood surrounded by the smoking ruins of the USSR’s severely damaged agricultural sector.

 Spooked by resultant economic and grain crises that threatened the empire’s ability to feed itself, and determined to exert his control over the hostile and strategically crucial countryside once and for all, Stalin regrouped. Now things got even more vicious, and there began a ‘Second Revolution’ that would finally break the back of a peasant class that clung to counterrevolutionary evils like private plots of land and a rural market economy. True communism would finally exist in the countryside and, crucially, the Communists would now control the empire’s food. Moreover, in Ukraine the war against the peasantry dovetailed with the destruction of Ukraine’s dangerous sense of independence from the Russian ‘big brother’. Thus, in the autumn of 1932, the Stalinist braintrust set out to create a terror-famine that would kill two birds with one stone: not only a stubborn and politically backwards peasantry, but a Ukrainian peasantry that was an important repository of Ukrainian national feeling. Communist activists now fanned out through the Ukrainian countryside to demand deliberate high grain quotas from farmers already struggling with the aftermath of poor harvests. Villages were surrounded by armed guards, who would requisition all the settlement’s food and shoot those accused of hoarding as well as anyone who tried to leave the now-starving community. Armed guard towers were erected in fields in order to ‘protect socialist property’, with soldiers machine-gunning starving peasants who dragged themselves amidst the picked-over crops in the hopes of finding sustenance.

 The first-person testimonies that survive from what historian Robert Conquest called the ‘vast Belsen’ of the Ukrainian countryside are suitably shocking. Conquest’s classic book about the famine, ‘Harvest of Sorrow’, reports of pregnant women beaten to death for plucking spring wheat, of children ‘choking, coughing with screams’, of Communist brigadiers carrying the dying to the graveyard as well as the dead, to save themselves the extra trip. People ate manure, dead dogs, dead humans, and finally nothing. In the village Mala Berezhanka, near Kyiv, a local authority shot seven people (two of them children) for being caught picking grain. But to single out a couple incidents is to belittle what happened, because such crimes were committed millions of times across much of a large country, until up to 10 million people had been murdered. The news of what was happening in Ukraine was largely kept from the masses in the USSR’s cities; foreign observers and journalists in the countryside, meanwhile, many of them Soviet- sympathising leftists who wanted to be fooled, were treated to Potemkin-style displays of the countryside’s robust health. Concurrently with the famine in Ukraine, and in the years that followed, Stalin’s regime mass murdered the urban Ukrainian intelligentsia in an attempt to eliminate once and for all the subversive idea of Ukrainian sovereignty. The upshot of the famine and the anti-Ukrainian repression in the short-term was that the regime won. Private, small-scale farming was wiped out, and large-scale industrial farming took its place. It was, however, a dubious victory for the regime, as Soviet industrial farming was disastrously inefficient. By the late 1930s, Soviet agriculture was worse off than it had been before the 1917 revolution, and the empire’s agricultural sector never recovered. Meanwhile, as history would prove, the regime didn’t quite manage to destroy the Ukrainian national identity.

Which brings us to the present moment, 75 years later after the famine became acute, and when the Ukrainian government is working to get the United Nations to acknowledge the Holodomor as a genocide, just like the Holocaust. Although a number of countries, including Canada, Australia, Poland, Hungary and the U.S., have recognised the Holodomor as a genocide, the issue remains tricky on the UN level. That’s because Russia is against a resolution, for one thing. But it’s also because the UN’s 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (CPPCG) defines genocide as a number of acts ‘committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group’. Stalin’s famine, however, was not waged against a racial or religious group. ‘Ethnical’ arguably enters into it, and ‘national’ comes closest, but neither are a perfect fit. Russians died in the Holodomor, the zone of which extended north of the Ukrainian border, and there were Ukrainian members of the Soviet hierarchy and of the NKVD. Indeed, the Famine could arguably be considered less as a unique attempt to eliminate the Ukrainian nation than as another atrocity in the history of a regime that used mass murder as a normal political weapon.

 The Kazakhs, Balts, Hungarians, Poles, Buryats, Chechens, Tatars, and various other groups unlucky enough to have come into contact with the Soviet empire can all credibly raise the issue of having been subjected by the Kremlin to mass murder and atrocities. So

Stalin’s ‘Second Revolution’ would break the back of a peasant class that clung to counterrevolutionary evils like private plots of land

for that matter can the Russians. On the other hand, the CPPCG was itself a political document. Because it required the Soviet UNI0N’s support, it excluded from its definition of genocide the killing of members of social classes or political, cultural, or ideological groups. It also excluded ‘cultural’ killings – such as the mass murder of a national intelligentsia. In other words, the resolution was rigged to favour Moscow, and is somewhat arbitrarily defined. It would only be a small stretch to say that it was defined expressly so that Moscow couldn’t be accused of anti-Ukrainian genocide. It’s too early to tell whether Ukraine’s genocide resolution will make it through the UN. But a bright sign is that the movement to recognize the Holodomor has been gathering energy for decades, and keeps rolling along. Conquest’s landmark 1984 book was released into a world for which Ukraine and its history were largely a blank spot, and in which many left-leaning Western intellectuals defended the Soviet UNI0N’s honour against charges of crimes against humanity. All that’s changed. Ukraine is on the upswing, and the Famine is now a widely-known historical fact. Whether Ukraine’s political gesture makes it through the UN on this try or not, the truth has won out in the end.

Mark Sabchuk


Go back


Comments (1)
You are not authorized! Only registered and authorized users can add their comments!
Yar | 19.05.2008 22:35

Very informative article on an important subject.

UkrainianHolocaust.org


 
Print Print   Send Send    In favorites In favorites

Read also:
  • A Stronghold of Rulers and Rebels
  • More Than A Square
  • Game of Thrones
  • A Divisive National Hero
  • The Ukrainian Roots of Sholem Aleichem

    Global news 
    Loading...
  • Events Calendar
    «« April 2018 »»
    Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
          1
    2 3 4 5 6 7 8
    9 10 11 12 13 14 15
    16 17 18 19 20 21 22
    23 24 25 26 27 28 29
    30

    Authorization
    Login:
    Password:
    Remember me
    Registration
    Forgot your password?

    Ukraine Truth
    Rights We Didn’t Know We Had

    Throughout EuroMaidan much has been made of Ukrainians making a stand for their rights. What exactly those rights are were never clearly defined. Ukraine ratified the Univer­sal Declaration of Human Rights in 1952. The first article of the Declaration states all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights, they are endowed with reason and conscience, and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood. The ousted and overthrown Ukrainian government showed to the world they don’t understand the meaning of these words.


    Kyiv Culture

    Pulling Strings
    Located on Hrushevskoho Street – the epicentre of EuroMaidan violence, home to battles, blazes and barricades – children’s favourite the Academic Puppet Theatre had to shut down in February. Nevertheless, it is getting ready to reopen this March with a renewed repertoire to bring some laughter back to a scene of tragedy. Operating (not manipulating) puppets is a subtle art that can make kids laugh and adults cry. What’s On meets Mykola Petrenko, art director of the Theatre, to learn more about those who pull the strings behind the show.

    more...


    Essential Kyiv listings
    Airports
    Airlines
    Car Rental
    Bars & Pubs
    Catering Services
    Cinemas
    Courier Services
    Education
    Foreign Banks
    Hotel Service
    Internet Cafes
    Lost & Found
    Medical Care
    Language Courses
    Nightlife
    Personal
    Restaurants
    Saunas
    Souvenir Shops
    Sports
    Taxi
    Travel Agencies
    Zoo
    Real Estate
    Cable & Satellite TV
    Fitness Centers
    Flowers and Gifts delivery
    Food Delivery
    Freight Forwarders
    Internet providers
    Russian/Ukrainian
    Translation Services
    Veterinarian Clinics
    Beauty Salons
    Whatson Birdies Party


    Useful Links